Skip to content

Let’s Not Overstate the Case

Like most Americans, particularly the non-communist ones, I watched the Super Bowl last night.

I’ve fallen out of love with football (of the American sort) in recent years. Mostly, I just don’t want to spend that much time watching sports. And as my six readers well know, I’m a baseball man.

Still, I have to admit that it was a damn fine game. I wasn’t terribly invested in the outcome but had a slight leaning toward the Saints, so that felt satisfying.

And oh, the trickery! The Saints led off the second half with an onside kick, which was exciting and unexpected and momentum-shifting. A great play call.

One announcer described it as “courageous.” A headline I saw this morning called it “valiant.”

Okay, look… I’m all for adding juice to headlines to suck in a reader, but really? Courageous? Valiant? I can get behind bold, gutsy, even ballsy, but I’m not sure that it takes courage to call for an unexpected onside kick. I could get behind imaginative, creative, or exhilarating. But no, that play call was not valiant.

Anyway, somehow I missed the Tim Tebow ad. I don’t know when it aired, but I plum missed it. And no, it doesn’t take courage for Tim to be publicly pro-life (thanks again, David Zirin).

Back in September, Zirin wrote about homophobia in the NFL. Kudos, David, for using the word gutsy to describe a couple of players’ stance in favor of gay marriage, rather than courageous or valiant.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


HTML tags are not allowed.